My Privacy My Decision: Control of Photo Sharing on Online Social Networks

My Privacy My Decision: Control of Photo Sharing on Online Social Networks

My Privacy My Decision: Control of Photo Sharing on Online Social Networks


My Privacy My Decision: Control of Photo Sharing on Online Social Networks,Photo sharing is an attractive feature which popularizes online social networks (OSNs). Unfortunately, it may leak users’ privacy if they are allowed to post, comment, and tag a photo freely. In this paper, we attempt to address this issue and study the scenario when a user shares a photo containing individuals other than himself/herself (termed co-photo for short). To prevent possible privacy leakage of a photo, we design a mechanism to enable each individual in a photo be aware of the posting activity and participate in the decision making on the photo posting. For this purpose, we need an efficient facial recognition (FR) system that can recognize everyone in the photo. However, more demanding privacy setting may limit the number of the photos publicly available to train the FR system. To deal with this dilemma, our mechanism attempts to utilize users’ private photos to design a personalized FR system specifically trained to differentiate possible photo co-owners without leaking their privacy. We also develop a distributed consensus-based method to reduce the computational complexity and protect the private training set. We show that our system is superior to other possible approaches in terms of recognition ratio and efficiency. Our mechanism is implemented as a proof of concept Android application on Facebook’s platform.


Photograph sharing is an alluring component which promotes Online Social Networks (OSNs). Shockingly, it might release clients’ protection in the event that they are permitted to post, remark, and tag a photograph uninhibitedly. In this paper, we endeavor to address this issue and study the situation when a client shares a photograph containing people other than himself/herself (named co-photograph for short). To avert conceivable protection spillage of a photograph, we plan a system to empower every person in a photograph know about the posting movement and take an interest in the basic leadership on the photograph posting. For this reason, we require an effective facial acknowledgment (FR) framework that can perceive everybody in the photograph. Be that as it may, additionally requesting protection setting may confine the quantity of the photographs openly accessible to prepare the FR framework. To manage this quandary, our component endeavors to use clients’ private photographs to outline a customized FR framework particularly prepared to separate conceivable photograph co-proprietors without releasing their security. We additionally build up a dispersed consensusbased technique to decrease the computational manysided quality and secure the private preparing set.

We demonstrate that our framework is better than other conceivable methodologies as far as acknowledgment proportion and effectiveness. Our system is actualized as a proof of idea Android application on Facebook’s stage. are urging clients to post co-photographs and tag their companions with a specific end goal to get more individuals included. Be that as it may, imagine a scenario in which the co-proprietors of a photograph are not willing to share. this photograph? Is it a protection infringement to share this cophoto without consent of the co-proprietors? Ought to the co-proprietors have some control over the co-photographs? To answer these inquiries, we have to expound on the protection issues over OSNs. Generally, protection is viewed as a condition of social withdrawal. As indicated by Altman’s protection direction hypothesis [1][15], security is a persuasion and dynamic limit direction handle where security is not static but rather “a specific control of get to to the self or to ones gathering”. In this hypothesis, “rationalization” alludes to the openness and closeness of self to others furthermore, “dynamic” means the coveted protection level changes with time as indicated by condition.

Amid the procedure of security control, we endeavor to coordinate the accomplished security level to the coveted one. At the ideal protection level, we can encounter the coveted certainty when we need to cover up or appreciate the coveted consideration when we need to appear. In any case, if the genuine level of security is more prominent than the coveted one, we will feel desolate or separated; then again, if the genuine level of security is littler than the coveted one, we will feel over-uncovered what’s more, defenseless. Tragically, on most current OSNs, clients have no control over the data showing up outside their profile page. In [21], Thomas, Grier and Nicol inspect how the absence of joint protection control can incidentally uncover touchy data about a client. To moderate this danger, they recommend Facebook’s security model to be adjusted to accomplish multi-party protection. In particular, there ought to be a commonly worthy protection strategy .

The Internet has become an evitable part of the lives of people today. Gone are the days when people would browse the net only to retain and even enhance their social lives through Social Networking Sites. By being aware of your cyber-surroundings and who you are talking to, you should be able to safely enjoy social networking online. Our intension is directed at the issue of privacy risk and user behaviour in order to suggest viable solutions for users to both improve their privacy protection, and be able to deploy the social functions expected from these types of network. A survey was conducted to study the effectiveness of the existing counter measure of un-tagging and shows that this counter measure is far from satisfactory users are worrying about offending their friends when un-tagging. As a result, they provide a tool to enable users to restrict others from seeing their photos when posted as a complementary strategy to protect privacy. However, this method will introduce a large number of manual tasks for end users. In, Squicciarini et al. propose a game-theoretic scheme in which the privacy policies are collaboratively enforced over the shared data [2]. This happens when the appearance of user has changed, or the photos in the training set are modified adding new images or deleting existing images.

The friendship graph may change over time [3][4]. Unfortunately, on most current OSNs, users have no control over the information appearing outside their profile page. In Thomas, Grier and Nicol examine how the lack of joint privacy control can inadvertently reveal sensitive information about a user. To mitigate this threat, they suggest Facebook’s privacy model to be adapted to achieve multi-party privacy. In these works, flexible access control schemes based on social contexts are investigated. However, in current OSNs, when posting a photo, a user is not required to ask for permissions of other users appearing in the photo. Basically, in our proposed one-against-one strategy a user needs to establish classifiers between self, friend and friend, friend also known as the two loops in Algorithm. During the first loop, there is no privacy concern of Alice’s friend list because friendship graph is undirected. However, in the second loop, Alice need to coordinate all her friends to build classifiers between them. According to our protocol, her friends only communicate with her and they have no idea of what they are computing for.

  • Mavridis et al. study the statistics of photo sharing on social networks and propose a three realms model: “a social realm, in which identities are entities, and friendship a relation; second, a visual sensory realm, of which faces are entities, and co-occurrence in images a relation; and third, a physical realm, in which bodies belong, with physical proximity being a relation.”
  • Choi et al. discuss the difference between the traditional FR system and the FR system that is designed specifically for OSNs. They point out that a customized FR system for each user is expected to be much more accurate in his/her own photo collections. A similar work is done, in which Choi et al. propose to use multiple personal FR engines to work collaboratively to improve the recognition ratio.


  • Currently there is no restriction with sharing of co-photos, on the contrary, social network service providers like Facebook are encouraging users to post co-photos and tag their friends in order to get more people involved.
  • Unfortunately, on most current OSNs, users have no control over the information appearing outside their profile page.

Proposed System

  • We propose a privacy-preserving distributed collaborative training system as our FR engine. In our system, we ask each of our users to establish a private photo set of their own. We use these private photos to build personal FR engines based on the specific social context and promise that during FR training, only the discriminating rules are revealed but nothing else.
  • In this paper, we propose a novel consensus based approach to achieve efficiency and privacy at the same time. The idea is to let each user only deal with his/her private photo set as the local train data and use it to learn out the local training result. After this, local training results are exchanged among users to form a global knowledge.
  • In the next round, each user learns over his/hers local data again by taking the global knowledge as a reference. Finally the information will be spread over users and consensus could be reached.
  • We show later that by performing local learning in parallel, efficiency and privacy could be achieved at the same time.


  • We propose to use private photos in a privacy-preserving manner and social contexts to derive a personal FR engine for any particular user.
  • Orthogonal to the traditional cryptographic solution, we propose a consensus-based method to achieve privacy and efficiency.


My Privacy My Decision: Control of Photo Sharing on Online Social Networks


Despite the spectrum of available privacy settings, users have no control over information appearing outside their immediate profile page. When a user posts a comment to a friend’s wall, he cannot restrict who sees the message. Similarly, if a user posts a photo and indicates the name of a friend in the photo, the friend cannot specify which users can view the photo. For both of these cases, Facebook currently lacks a mechanism to satisfy privacy constraints when more than one user is involved. This leads to privacy conflicts, where asymmetric privacy requirements result in one user’s privacy being violated. Privacy conflicts publicly expose personal information, slowly eroding a user’s privacy.

Related Work

A paper on “Privacy-Preserving Photo Sharing Based on a Secure JPEG” by Lin Yuan, Pavel Korshunov and Touradi Ebrahimi[3] designed a framework which is based on secure JPEG framework that integrates diff. tools to protect photo privacy. There are various tools to ensure the image privacy such as filtering, encryption, scrambling. In this paper general scrambling is used. To secure metadata authors does the encryption of selected JPEG metadata in the exchangeable image file format (Exif) tag. Author has designed server which hosts only secure photos uploaded by users. Also author has developed a multiregion selective JPEG scrambling scheme. This framework prevents unauthorized access to photos, automatic identification recognition and image data mining.

A paper on “Collaborative Face Recognition for Improved Face Annotation in Personal Photo Collection” by Jae Young Choi, Wesley De Neve, Yong Man Ro[2] proposed a system in which distributed approach( multiple FR engines) is used to perform operations such as subject identification and verification. Most of the existing system have been developed by using centralized approach like video surveillance, national security. In this paper author believes that multiple FR engines-belonging to members with close relationships can improve the accuracy of face annotation. Two key issues are addressed here: first one is the selection of expert FR engines that are able to recognize query face image. And 2nd one is the merging of multiple FR results into a single FR result. Here for the selection of multiple FR engines social graph model(SGM) is constructed. SGM is created by using personal photo collections shared in the collaborative FR framework. Detected images are forwarded to selected FR engines. Then results are merged by using diff face extractors and classifiers. Finally we get the accurate face annotation. Large amount of attention is required for the creation of this framework.

A paper on “Moving Beyond Untagging: Photo Privacy in Tagged World” by Andrew Besmer and Heather Richter Lipford[1] proposed a system in which “Restrict others” tool is used to address photo privacy. It works by allowing tagged users to send a request to the owner asking that a photo be hidden from certain people. The tagged user is able to set the custom permissions at the individual photo level. This tool promotes sharing by reducing the need for the tagged user to untag the photo or restrict all their tagged photos. This tool lets user specify individuals or groups of users they would like to restrict the photo from.

A paper on “Autotagging Facebook: Social Network Context Improves Photo Annotation” by Zak Stone, Todd Zickler, Trevor Darrell[4] proposed a framework in which task of automatic face recognition in personal photographs is done. Author combine face recognition scores with social context in a conditional random field (CRF) model and apply this model to label faces in photos from the popular online social network Facebook, which is now the top photo-sharing site on the Web with billions of photos in total.


My Privacy My Decision: Control of Photo Sharing on Online Social Networks,Photograph sharing is a standout amongst the most famous elements in online informal communities, for example, Facebook. Lamentably, imprudent photograph posting may uncover protection of people in a posted photograph. To check the protection spillage, we proposed to empower people conceivably in a photograph to give the authorizations before posting a co-photograph. We composed a protection saving FR framework to distinguish people in a co-photograph. The proposed framework is included with low calculation cost and privacy of the preparation set. Hypothetical investigation and tests were directed to show adequacy and effectiveness of the proposed conspire. We expect that our proposed plan be extremely helpful in ensuring clients’ security in photograph/picture sharing over online informal communities. Be that as it may, there dependably exist exchange off amongst security and utility. For instance, in our present Android application, the co-photograph must be post with consent of all the co-proprietors. Inertness presented in this procedure will extraordinarily affect client experience of OSNs. More over, neighborhood FR preparing will deplete battery rapidly. Our future work could be the manner by which to move the proposed preparing plans to individual mists like Dropbox as well as icloud.